In this article we will discuss some detail insights of Granite VS Quartz Countertops, this discussion has been around from quite a while & we decided to help you to understand Pros & Cons between Granite VS Quartz Countertops.
Both the materials granite and quartz are vital in the interior of any household be it the kitchen islands or bathroom countertops. They are used widely for making the ambient pleasant. Granite is a kind of natural rock and is a bit high maintenance considering the sealing required after a year or so. The benefit of using granite is that it is less expensive than quartz.
On the other hand, Quartz is a type of natural mineral which is processed by the addition of manmade resins. Quartz due to its chemical composition is more likely to get damaged due to high temperature and heat. But they are low maintenance otherwise and usually are at lesser risk of staining.
Quartz Pros & Cons
It has its fair share of pros and cons, and they are given below:
Quartz Countertops pros
- Generally, the strength of quartz is equivalent to that of granite, but they have additional flexibility due to which they have lesser chances of cracking.
- Unlike granite, quartz does not require any sealing after some time because of its porous nature that is why they are considered less maintenance as compared to granite.
- Quartz is resistant to any kind of staining so in case of any spilling emergency; you have nothing to worry about.
Quartz Countertops Cons
- Even though quartz is very flexible and durable but still cannot be deemed as indestructible and can break under immense pressure.
- While very durable they cannot be considered indestructible. They are stain-resistant so dropping a glass of wine on them simply requires a quick cleanup.
- Another big disadvantage of using quartz is that it is prone to discoloration in case of extensive exposure to the sun. The discoloration usually occurs because one part gets more sunlight than others and hence the difference in colour.
- Also, the seam is usually prominent in quartz slabs, but you can get it covered if you choose a darker colour.
Granite Countertops Pros & cons
Like quartz, granite also has its advantages and disadvantages which are mentioned below:
Granite Countertops Pros
- This needs sealing every year so, during the time you have a granite countertop in your house, you need to keep an eye on its maintenance.
- It is extremely durable because of its non-porous nature and is a lifelong investment if maintained properly.
Granite Countertops Cons
- Like quartz, granite is also not indestructible and is more likely to cracking or damage when exposing to high pressure.
- Unlike quartz, the seams are almost impossible to hide because of its natural appearance but can be made less prominent by using a quality fabricator.
- Another disadvantage is that there is a slight difference of appearance to the granite slabs you order but handpicking a slab yourself can prevent such unpleasant surprises.
Both granite and quartz have the highs and lows, and it depends on your desire that which one you go for. You cannot just rate one higher than the other sweepingly because the one that is best for you may not be the best for others. There are a huge number of reviews available online for both the materials and it can also help you select the better choice by knowing the personal experience of people. But still, no one can tell you what is good for you other than yourself because you know each minor detail of your requirement. Also, you know what kind of countertop will complement the overall look of the kitchen and interior.
Comparison of Quartz Vs Granite Countertops cost
Usually, quartz is more expensive than granite. The cost of normal standard quartz starts from 70$ and that of granite starts from 40$ per square foot. A top quality quartz cost around 180$ per square foot and high-end granite has a cost of around 190$ per square foot. So there is not too much cost difference between both the materials and your pockets have to bear the burden if you want to get good quality. For a 30 square feet quartz countertop, you will need a budget of around 2500$ to 3300$. Generally, you will have to pay lesser for granite countertops under the same specifications, but the scarcity and quality of granite stone can make it more costly. The cost of granite countertops has taken a nose dive in the recent past as there was a time when it was more costly than quartz. The immense neck to neck competition that quartz gave to granite made granite manufacturers to drop the prices to increase demand and quartz manufacturers did the contrary. You have the freedom of going either way as far as the budget is concerned because the cost difference between the two is not extravagant. You might choose the more suitable one for you that fulfills your requirements even if you have to pay a few times more.
Which looks better Granite VS Quartz Countertops
When it comes to aesthetics, it is usually a very personal decision because in the end, it all comes down to you that which one you feel better If you have made your mind that this one is the right choice for me then no matter what others say, you will stick to it. They are beautiful custom made countertops of different colours and patterns are available for both materials, and it is up to you to choose the one. Quartz is more overrated aesthetically than granite with multimillion brands making products like Cambria and Caesar stone. Similarly, brands like sapiens one make topnotch granite countertops that are pleasant to look at. It is human nature to go for more better choices. Some people would prefer granite over quartz and vice versa without considering the specification in details. It is just that which one grabs your attention first, and you feel like having it.
Which one is more popular?
Granite was the most popular choice before the ’90s and the automatic choice for renovation needs of the interior. It stayed as the first choice for many over the years because of its look and durability. But as the time passed by, the popularity of granite starting dropping and quartz emerged as an alternative. It became the new hit and more luxurious option for an interior. Home improvement companies, real estate sector and media have also given the hype to quartz that resulted in its popularity. But despite the booming popularity of quartz, granite is still the best selling material for countertops in the market. Also, the elevating prices of quartz are causing its popularity to drop down, and people are considering to opt for the conventional option of granite countertops.
Which one is more volatile?
Both the materials have a certain level of volatility due to their chemical composition. Both include volatile organic compounds (VOCs) in them. As quartz is made of 10% resin (epoxy binder) and 90% pure quartz that is why the volatility of granite is generally higher than granite. But granite also contains a trace of radon which has a volatile nature, but its quantity is negligible.
Return on investment (ROI)
The worth of your house increases when you and any stone countertop to your interior be it granite or quartz. Unlike other renovations that do not yield any fruitful outcome ROI, stone countertops can certainly make your house worthy. The usage of a high-quality countertop can also make the selling of house faster because of its easy on the eyes appearance. Usually, a potential buyer will be turned off as soon as he sets eye on laminate because of its maintenance and appearance. If you have an appropriate countertop that is complementing the surrounding environment of the interior, then you have a great chance of attracting any buyer. If they like the setting, they may go as high as giving you 100% return on investment of countertops.
The impact on the environment
The environmental benefits while using any product should be kept in mind. The recycling ability of any material also makes it a better choice for the environment. While we compare quartz and granite, quartz has a better impact on the environment as it has less carbon release. Today’s consumers are trying to make the best sustainable choices when remodelling their homes. Regarding countertops, quartz materials generally leave less of a carbon footprint. Both of these materials contain content that can be recycled for future usage. Quartz is mined all across the world and then shipped to countries wherever they are required. Granite is extracted through digging and sent to manufacturers anywhere in the world. But considering all the aspects of friendliness to the environment, quartz countertops take over granite. Quartz countertops also save natural resources like fossil fuels. Many quartz manufacturers like Cambria are Green guard certified which means that they have no adverse effects on air quality and environment. Both granite and quartz need a lot of energy for the manufacturing process. The durability factor of both materials makes them a sustainable choice because they can last for lifespan if properly taken care of.
Conclusion Granite VS Quartz Countertops
The granite and quartz have their pros and cons, and it is hard to make a sweeping statement. Cost of granite is lesser than quartz generally, but there is not a significant difference. Both have an aesthetic influence on the interior of the house. Quartz and granite countertops come in all kind of patterns, colours and designs. Considering all these factors from cost to environmental impacts, I personally think quartz is a better choice. Keep this in mind that this analysis could go either way because there is not a big difference in advantages and disadvantages of both materials.